Phunye Sele Sele new signing Fiston Abduol Razak struck on 38 minutes at the Dr Molemela Stadium, Luvolwethu Mpeta earning Baxter’s side a share of the spoils in the 64th minute.
The point earned allowed Matsatsantsa to move on equal points with eighth-placed Celtic, although they have an inferior goal difference.
Although Baxter had been hoping for all three points, he had no complaints about the outcome.
“You’re always wanting to win games but considering the amount of time we’ve done the work and considering the weather and the opponents, away from home, then I think you’re happy enough with a point in those circumstances,” Baxter said.
“I think our play around the box, we saw shots of it, but we didn’t see it enough. We were still looking for that golden bullet a little bit individually.