Update

GEORGE NEWS - The Engineering Council of South Africa (Ecsa) has cancelled the registration of the engineer on the disastrous Neo Victoria building project and removed his name from the Ecsa register.

It also imposed the maximum permissible fine on him. According to Ecsa's president, TC Madikane, the respondent has until 3 August to appeal the decision. 

Madikane spoke at a media briefing in George on Saturday, during Public Works Minister Dean MacPherson's visit to the survivors and families impacted by the building collapse.

Madikane did not name the engineer, but in media reports following the building collapse on 6 May last year, he was reported to be Atholl Mitchell of the firm Mitchell and Associates in Cape Town. At the time of the collapse, he was under investigation by Ecsa for a complaint laid in 2023.

In an earlier complaint in 2019, there was insufficient evidence to support a breach of the Code of Conduct.

Ecsa suspended the respondent in June 2024 pending its investigation into the collapse. 

Based on the findings of the final report that had been concluded earlier, five charges were brought against him for contravening the rules of Ecsa's Code of Conduct and Code of Practice.

A hearing was held on 29 and 30 May this year at which the respondent was not present, after he had declined to attend. According to Madikane, a plea of not guilty was entered on the engineer's behalf.

The verdict was guilty on all charges of violating the following rules in the Code of Conduct:

• Rule 3.1(a) - Failure to discharge duties to employers, clients, associates and the public with due care, skill and diligence;
• Rule 3.1(c) - Failure to adhere to professional norms when carrying out work;
• Rule 3.2(g) - Misrepresentation of academic or professional qualifications or competency;
• Rule 3.3(a) - Failure to give due regard to and prioritise the health, safety and interests of the public; and
• Rule 8.1 of the Code of Practice - Failure to comply with relevant legislation, including the Engineering Profession Act, Occupational Health and Safety Act, National Building Regulations and Building Standards Act and National Environmental Management Act.

Engineer credentialling

At the briefing, MacPherson said one of the measures being proposed to prevent similar disasters in future is the introduction of a national credentialling scheme for built environment professionals to "distinguish the specialised skill sets from the generalists who are already professionally registered. 

In the immediate, the first will be to address structural engineers working on high-risk buildings. It will no longer be enough to simply be professionally registered. Engineers will need to prove their competence for complex projects, just like pilots or surgeons."

Reports
The Ecsa report as well as the recently completed report of the Council for the Built Environment have been submitted to the police and will form part of the criminal investigation. 

The only outstanding report on the building collapse is the one from the Employment and Labour Department.

MacPherson said he has 'implored' the Employment and Labour Minister, Nomakhosazana Meth, to finalise it and also urgently attend to the financial compensation for those injured in the collapse.

‘We bring you the latest Garden Route, Hessequa, Karoo news’